A Meeting Place for Evangelicals, Reformed, and Orthodox Christians

Category: Discipleship (Page 6 of 9)

Reformed Food Fight

 

food-fighting-1Something like a food fight recently erupted in one corner of the Reformed world.  Pastor Toby Sumpter wrote “Free Range, Gluten Free Yoga vs. Jesus” in which he criticized the concern among some Christians with “eating well” as part of an “idolatry problem.”  This posting generated quite a bit of reaction and not a little push back from some folks leading Pastor Doug Wilson to write “Food Libertarian.” In “Fear, Shame, and Guilt at Lunch”  Pastor Wilson warns that those who are overly concerned about food may be in danger of “foodalatry.”  This controversy led Brad Littlejohn to write “The ‘All I Really Meant…’ Syndrome” article on his blog.

 

Theological Issues That Lies Beneath the Surface

As a former Reformed Christian I found this controversy over food more significant than might appear at first blush.  The various articles inadvertently shed an interesting light on the Reformed tradition’s relationship with contemporary culture and its understanding of embodied spirituality.

I suspect that part of what is adding to the controversy is that while Reformed theological tradition has a lot to say about Christology, the sacraments, and predestination, it has had little to say about food and Christian living.  This has not been much of an issue for Reformed Christians if Western European culture is assumed to be “Christian.”  But with the recent dramatic shifts in American eating habits and the emergence of new perspectives on food some Calvinists are wondering how to respond.  Some embrace the new perspectives on food while others resist making changes to their eating habits.  Another contributing factor may be dominionist theology which insists on making the Christian faith applicable to all areas of life.  As I read the various postings I noticed the tension between legalism and antinomianism.  There also seemed to be an unspoken tension about how the Reformed faith relates to our bodies and our physical wellbeing.

One surprising discovery for this former Calvinist is Orthodoxy’s rich spiritual heritage with respect to food and eating.  This heritage of spiritual wisdom draws from the monasteries and from Orthodoxy’s deep roots into particular cultures.  Coming from an Evangelical church background where we frequently ate out quite often for fellowship we never gave much thought about what we ate or how we ate.  When I became Orthodox I was surprised to learn that eating was part of Orthodox discipleship.  In the catechism class I learned that the spiritual discipline of fasting is just as much a part of Orthodoxy as the use of icons in worship.  It made sense in light of the mind-spirit-body unity but still it was a shock learning to apply Orthodoxy’s fasting disciplines to my life.  Another surprise has been learning that Orthodoxy’s ancient wisdom tradition has much to say about food and eating.

Where Reformed Christianity tends to be cerebral, Orthodoxy is more holistic.  When I was an Evangelical and when I attended a Reformed seminary, food was a peripheral issue for theology.  But in Orthodoxy food is part of our embodied spirituality.  Approached properly (Christianly) food and eating can promote spiritual growth.  And, approached unwarily or carelessly food and eating can injure our spiritual well being.

 

Robin Phillips

Robin Phillips

Robin Phillips’ Take

An interesting theological perspective on this debate can be found in Robin Phillips’ articles. Phillips knows the key players involved.  As a bright astute scholar he is sensitive to the fact that underlying the recent debate about food are issues about the relationship between the Christian and Creation, in particular physical matter and our bodies.

See his article “Jesus, Junk Food, and Christian Charity” in which he wrote:

In the end, the notion that God doesn’t care what we eat colludes with the Gnostic idea that the physical body is unimportant to God, that what really matters is the things of the spirit.

If accurate, this assessment has troubling implications for Reformed theology!

 

An Orthodox Approach to Healthy Eating

I have been blessed recently to attend a class taught by Rita Madden, the host of Ancient Faith Radio program: Food, Faith, and Fasting.  In her presentations she combines scientific research with the ancient wisdom of the Church.  What struck me as I listened to her presentations has been how holistic and balanced the Orthodox approach to life is.

 

Some of her talk titles are listed below:

 

In her article “Eating in an Anciently Refreshing Way” Rita discussed how the modern food industry has drastically reshaped America’s eating habits and how people are turning to all kinds of diet in order to counter the side effects of the new modern food products.  One thing I learned has been the fact that God made natural food and that food is meant to be a gift that brings us closer to God.  There has arisen a secularized view that sees food as fuel for the body or as something like a drug, something that lifts us up when we’re down or soothes us when we’re stressed.  So I find her talks helpful to bringing balance and perspective to my spiritual life.

I invite our readers to compare how Orthodoxy and the Reformed tradition understand the relationship between food, eating, and Christian spirituality.  I’m sure some will be pleasantly surprised by what they find!

Robert Arakaki

 

Family Concerns and Converting to Orthodoxy

 

Making the transition to Orthodoxy is often far from easy.  Even if the inquirer comes to the conclusion that Orthodoxy is the true Faith, they may have family concerns that hold them back from taking the final step of converting to Orthodoxy.

I have included an excerpt from ‘C’ who expressed his concerns for his family spiritual wellbeing and Fr. Isaiah Gillette’s response to these concerns.

Orthodox Mission in West Feliciana, Louisiana

St. John Orthodox Mission in Starhill – West Feliciana parish, Louisiana   Source: The Advocate

‘C’ wrote:

You asked what would I miss if I were to leave an evangelical church for Orthodoxy. The main thing is this.

A.     Family focused ministry
B.     Feeling welcomed and pushed to love others
C.     Feeling challenged in growth by the pastor

 

Even with all this I would probably be joining a Orthodox church because I do believe they hold the truth. The main reason I have not done so is due to my family. My wife has pretty much followed me on my journey intellectually in accepting the truth that the Orthodox church teaches. However, neither of us feels that the Orthodox church is the best place to raise our children in teaching them to love Christ and love others. This has been the biggest concern for first my wife and then me as she has spoken to me about it.

 

Fr.  Isaiah’s reponse:

A. Family focused ministry

I hear this phrase often used about evangelical churches. Too often what it means is that they split the family up for almost every activity, especially the most important activity, the Sunday morning worship service. I am a firm believer in the importance of Christian education: Sunday School, yes. Youth group, yes. Adult Bible study, yes. But it should not come as a substitute for attending worship together as a family. Here’s why:

1. The Divine Liturgy is by far the most important teaching tool for our faith. Even without a sermon, every vital truth of the Christian faith is there: the Holy Trinity, the Incarnation of the Word of God, the Cross, the Grave, the Resurrection, the descent of the Holy Spirit, and Christ’s eternal presence with us in the sacrament of Holy Communion. A good sermon is frosting on the cake.

2. Modeling. Children will never grow properly to a strong adult faith without seeing their parents pray and worship God. When children see and hear parents proclaiming the faith through the Nicene Creed, or singing “Lord, have mercy” sincerely, or going to the priest for confession, or making the sign of the Cross, they learn that this is important.

3. Simply put, even very young children know when there is something exciting going on, and they are being shuffled off to the nursery, “children’s church,” or whatever. “Let the children come to Him,” learn the hymns, smell the incense, cross themselves, help Mama bake communion bread. And don’t forget that your home is a “little church,” the place where children learn to bring the faith home and practice the lessons they learn at Church.

Do young children get antsy in worship? Of course! Take a book or a doll, or, better yet, help them get interested in what’s going on: “Look, here comes Father with the incense… Now we are going to stand up to hear the Gospel, because it is very important.” Etc.

If you still think your local Orthodox Church needs to do more for children, talk to your priest, and volunteer to get involved. There may already be more going on than you know. Most Orthodox Churches in the U.S. have a link to a Church-sponsored summer camp. Many of my fellow priests are the products of such camping ministries.

See: Antiochian Village (near Pittsburgh, PA) & Saint Nicholas Ranch (near Fresno, CA)

 

B. Feeling welcomed and pushed to love others 

I have never attended an Orthodox Church where I did not feel welcomed. OK, maybe there have been a few people who were put off that I did not speak Greek, or Russian, or Arabic, or Serbian. But a smile and handshake usually breaks the ice. And showing a sincere interest in the Orthodox faith usually results in meeting people who are happy to share their traditions. There may be a few parishes where people are not used to others converting to the Orthodox faith, and wonder why you would go to all the effort. But most Orthodox in this country know people in their own parish who have made the leap – they are likely to be the first ones you meet.

Having said that, I can also say that I have never attended an Orthodox Church (or any other kind) where there was not someone who I did not get along with. There are just some personalities that are so different from mine that it is much more work to love them as I should. That’s where the “push” comes in; worshiping alongside “difficult” people (like me!) is our opportunity to lay down our own will out of love for our neighbor.

In any Orthodox Church, you will have plenty of opportunities to feel welcomed, and to be pushed to love others.

 

C. Feeling challenged in growth by the pastor 

Here is another opportunity to talk with the local priest about your needs and hopes. Try to be open to the many ways that growth can take place. If you are coming from an evangelical background, you probably have a good exposure to the Bible. That’s great, bring it with you and let it grow, now fertilized by the Spirit-inspired teaching of the Church fathers. Listen to the words of the Divine Liturgy and other services of the Church. They are completely filled with Scripture.

The total burden for spiritual growth cannot rest on any one person, not even the most gifted and devout priest. He’s not going to preach for 30-40 minutes like your evangelical pastor (even though St. John Chrysostom and other early priests and bishops certainly did!). Keep reading! Get suggestions from your priest and fellow Orthodox Christians. Find out where the nearest monastery is, and visit as often as you can. This gives your children exposure to some real heroes of our faith.

I’m sorry to go on so long. I feel passionately about growing faith in families of our Orthodox Churches. This can be a most exciting and enriching environment in which to teach children to love Christ and others. Please let me know if there is any way I can be helpful to you on your journey. May God bless and lead you.

In Christ our Savior,
Fr. Isaiah Gillette

Childrens' Church

Protestant Childrens’ Church – Notice the difference?

 

 

 

Saint Nicholas and the Meaning of Christmas

 

Icon - St. Nicholas of Myra

Icon – St. Nicholas of Myra

Has the meaning of Christmas changed in recent years?  Has the creeping commercialism of the past 40 years radically reshaped our understanding of Christmas?  We learn in the news about Black Friday and Green Monday, about record sales and great bargains, and sadly about customers fighting other customers so they can get the perfect gift for their loved ones.  Television shows talk about our having “the best Christmas ever!”  It is as if Christmas is a rush that brings us perfect happiness.  Perhaps this commercialization of Christmas has not corrupted the meaning of Christmas for many, but we suspect that it certainly has for millions.  How did American culture go so wrong when it comes to celebrating Christmas?

Part of the problem is the fact that many people get much of their understanding of Christmas through the mass media which is heavily dependent on advertising revenue to survive.  In many ways, this form of capitalist consumerism has come to dominate the Christmas season dangerously obscuring its traditional meaning.

 

If asked point blank about the meaning of Christmas, how would your 10-12 year old children answer?  Could they discuss the central meaning of Christmas?  What we really ought to  celebrate in Christmas?

Rather than react negatively to all this, we can respond positively by learning from Saint Nicholas of Myra, the original “Santa Claus.”  The name “santa” comes from the word “saint” and the name “Claus” is a shortened form of “Nicholas.”  Unlike the modern mythical chubby figure who flies around the world on Christmas Eve in a sled pulled by flying reindeer there was a real live Santa in history.  Nicholas of Myra lived in Asia Minor (modern day Turkey) in the fourth century.  He was much beloved and shortly after he died he was remembered as a great saint by Christians in both the East and West.  In recent years people have forgotten about the first Santa and were taught a “new and improved” Santa who brings lots and lots of toys to good girls and boys.  For a discussion of how modern society redefined “Santa Claus” see my 2011 posting “Remembering St. Nicholas, Recovering a Christian Heritage.”

 

Learning from Saint Nicholas

Lesson 1 – Standing up for the Orthodox Faith

In Christmas we celebrate the birth of the Son of God who came into the world for our salvation.  There is truth in the saying: “Christ is the reason for the season.”  The true meaning of Christmas rests on right doctrine.  A heretical understanding of Christ poses a deadly threat to the Christmas season.  If Jesus is not truly the Son of God then Christmas is a waste of time.  All the twinkling Christmas lights, Christmas caroling, and eggnog drink and cookies are all for nothing if Jesus is not the Son of God.

We do not celebrate Christ coming into our hearts spiritually at Christmas. No, the Christ of the Christmas season is the true Logos of God who comes physically into human history, taking on flesh “becoming Incarnate of the Virgin Mary” as the Nicene Creed so rightly says. God took on true humanity in Christ, becoming like us so He might redeem a fallen human race by conquering both sin and death.  In the Incarnation the Word of the God invaded human history to rescue us.  The birth of Christ is just as real as D Day (6 June 1945) when the Allied forces landed in Normandy to bring about the end of Hitler’s evil rule.  Here, moderns might rightly say the Incarnation is “massive”!

We learn from Saint Nicholas the importance of holding to a right faith in Christ.  Saint Nicholas was more than a nice guy.  He was bishop of the church.  As bishop he was responsible for guarding the Christian Faith.  When the Arian heresy surfaced denying that Jesus Christ was truly divine, Bishop Nicholas and other bishops met to uphold Christ’s divinity: “true God of true God, begotten, not made, of one essence with the Father.”  There is the story that at the Council of Nicea (AD 325) Nicholas was so upset at hearing Arius’ blasphemy that he slugged Arius in the face.  This is a saint willing to fight for the faith!  Not some jolly old man sitting in a chair with children on his lap.

 

Lesson 2 – Giving to the Poor

Santa’s big bag of toys and his surprise visits on Christmas Eve come from the story of a poor man who had three daughters.  Because he could not afford to pay his daughters’ dowry they were in danger of being forced into prostitution in order to survive.  Out of humility Nicholas would come in the middle of the night and throw in a bag of coin for each of the three daughters.  When the father caught Nicholas in the act he began to thank him, but Nicholas stopped him saying that it was not him who should be thanked but God alone.  In another version of the story the daughters would wash their stocking and hang them during the night to dry.  Nicholas deposited gold coins in the stocking in the middle of the night to help them.

The story of Saint Nicholas rescuing the three young daughters can be applied to the modern problem of human trafficking.  Human trafficking (sexual slavery, forced labor, or organ harvesting) is a humanitarian crisis today involving some 2.5 million people in over 120 countries (United Nations).  Because poverty is one of the major driving forces underlying human trafficking — Almsgiving can be a major means of addressing this problem.

Almsgiving is more than writing out a check to a worthy cause; Christian almsgiving is rooted in a spirituality radically different from secular charity.  I recommend the reader read Todd Madigan’s insightful “The Advent of Modern Almsgiving.”

In addition to supporting organizations that combat human trafficking, Orthodox Christians can also remember to pray for the victims and perpetrators during the Divine Liturgy.  There is one petition that can apply to the issue of human trafficking:

For those who travel, by land, sea and air, for those who are sick or suffering or in captivity, and for their safekeeping, let us pray to the Lord.

 

Lesson 3 – Being Open to Miracles

St. Nicholas praying for deliverance

St. Nicholas praying for deliverance

Saint Nicholas is also known as Nicholas the Wonderworker.  His life story is full of miracles and deliverances.  He once went on a pilgrimage to Jerusalem by boat.  Along the way the ship ran into a fierce storm that threatened to capsize the boat and take the life of all on board.  Saint Nicholas prayed fervently for the safety of the passengers and in answer to his prayers the sea became calm once again.  On another occasion he rescued three men who were unjustly accused by snatching the sword out of the executioner’s hand.

Nicholas’ charismatic ministry continued even after his death.  He was buried in Myra and the town became a popular pilgrimage site.  People would visit his grave site and ask for his prayers.  When the Muslims conquered Asia Minor, a group of sailors hurriedly dug up Nicholas’ bones and transported them to the town of Bari in southern Italy.  Parts of his relics were also taken to the city of Venice.  His posthumous popularity among ordinary Christians can be traced to his devotion to Christ and his reputation as an effective intercessor.

 

Lesson 4 – Embracing Asceticism

From childhood Nicholas strove to live a holy life dedicated to Christ.  At an early age he devoted himself to the reading of the Bible and other spiritual works.  He gave himself to prayer day and night.  He was the first to arrive at church.  When his predecessor died an elderly bishop had a vision informing him that the first person to enter the church that night was to be made the next archbishop of Myra.  When the saint arrived before anyone else he was stopped by the elder who asked him: “What is your name, child?”  God’s chosen one replied: “My name is Nicholas, Master, and I am your servant.”  Nicholas wanted to retire to the desert as a monk but he heard a voice telling him that this was not his calling.  The Lord told Nicholas: “Nicholas, this is not the vineyard where you shall ear fruit for Me.  Return to the world, and glorify My Name there.”

For modern day Orthodox Christians Saint Nicholas can serve as an example reminding us that devotion to God can be as simple as coming to the Liturgy on time.  It is a sad fact that many Orthodox Christians straggle into the Sunday worship rather than eagerly participating in the Liturgy.

The ascetic life involves the disciplines of prayer, Bible reading, fasting, and almsgiving.  All these spiritual disciplines can be found in the pre-Christmas fast observed by Orthodoxy.  This is probably one of the biggest adjustments Protestants need to make when they become Orthodox.  Many Protestants in America view the Christmas season as a joyful time of caroling, shopping, Christmas festivities, and children opening presents around the Christmas tree on Christmas morning.  The notion of Lent during Christmas seems almost a contradiction in terms.  Yet fasting and Christmas do go together.  If Christmas is about preparing the way for the Son of God who would one day die on the Cross for our then fasting, mourning, and repentance are very appropriate ways for us to anticipate Christmas.  Too many modern Christians take a pick-and-choose approach to spirituality.  They choose only the feasting; historically, however, the church fathers taught feasting rests upon prior fasting.  The cycle of fasting-feasting is an integral part of Orthodox spirituality.  The Christmas Nativity is about the Christ Child who was born to rule and born to die.  Thus, Christmas is both a time of joy and mourning (see Luke 6:20-26).

 

A “Countercultural” Approach to Christmas

Many Christians lament how Christmas has become commercialized and how the true meaning of Christmas has been lost.  Rather than complain, we can respond positively by following the example of Saint Nicholas of Myra and observing Christmas the Orthodox way.  The advantage of Orthodoxy’s Christmas Lent is that it is not a knee-jerk reaction to contemporary trends, but based on following Holy Tradition which has been passed down over many generations.  This gives Orthodox Christians spiritual stability even as secular understanding of Christmas morphs in bizarre ways.

What can the Orthodox do to hold on to the true meaning of Christmas?  We can make an effort honor Saint Nicholas on his feast day (December 6) at church even if it falls on the middle of the week.  In the video below we see an Orthodox parish in San Anselmo, California, gathered on a Wednesday to celebrate St. Nicholas feast day.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s2gr-JJjpEg

If we attend mid-week services to celebrate Saint Nicholas’ feast day that will surely make a huge impact on our children.  We can tell them about Saint Nicholas’ devotion to prayer, fasting, and almsgiving as an example to follow during the Christmas fast.

We can support charitable organizations that help those in need.  We can support organizations that combat human trafficking while we also pray more fervently when the Divine Liturgy exhorts us to pray for those “in captivity.”  One possibility is supporting organizations like Samaritana – “Towards Prostitution-Free Societies.”

Parents can buy an icon of Saint Nicholas and teach their children about the first Santa Claus who was a real person who lived in the fourth century.  Saint Nicholas’ life story is full of interesting and inspiring stories that we can pass on to our children.  We can teach them the hymns of the church about Saint Nicholas.  We can teach children that Saint Nicholas is in heaven praying for us.

Kontakion 1

O champion wonderworker and superb servant of Christ
thou who pourest out for all the world
the most precious myrrh of mercy
and an inexhaustible sea of miracles
I praise thee with love, O Saint Nicholas;
and as thou art one having boldness toward the Lord, from all dangers do thou deliver us,
that we may cry to thee:    Rejoice, O Nicholas, Great Wonderworker!

 

In conclusion, celebrating Christmas in the spirit of Saint Nicholas is an act of radical discipleship.  The original Saint Nicholas was not some jolly old man but a radical Christian.  Let us learn from him and make our Christmas an Orthodox Christmas.

Robert Arakaki

 

« Older posts Newer posts »